Who Wrote Hudaibiya Agreement
Ali asked Khalid if he knew what he had been asked or not. Khalid replied, “I don`t worry about what it is. I will write what they tell me: as soon as the Prophet is made aware of the scriptures, he will know what to do with them. Khalid wrote the case and we took it to the Prophet, who ordered someone to read it. Here too, the texts differ. The texts of the Shia hadiths agree that the Prophet (SA) himself erased the words in which Ali (AS) wrote “Muhammad ibn `Abdillah” after Ali (AS) refused to erase the holy words. In these texts, and in some texts of Ahl al-Sunnah Ahadith, it is explicitly pointed out that the Prophet (SA) asked Ali (AS) to show him the words by placing his hand on the words so that he could erase the words with his own hands. “The Prophet told Ali to show him the words. Ali did the same, after which the Prophet erased the words and Muhammad ibn wrote `Abdillah`. It is said that once at the time of the conquest, a singer was brought to al-Muhajir b. Abu Umayya who had publicly sung satirical poems about Hadrat Abu Bakr. Muhajir`s hand was amputated. When the Caliph heard this news, he was shocked and wrote a letter to Muhajir with the following words: “Ali (AS) did this and the Prophet (SA) removed the words `Messenger of Allah` from his own hand.
Then Ali (AS) wrote “ibn `Abdillah” instead. Therefore, it was `Ali (AS) who wrote the letter and not the Prophet (SA). On the contrary, the Prophet (SA) did not read or write in accordance with the accounts of the Shiites and those of the Ahl al-Sunnah. The Prophet (AS) explained that he wanted to do nothing but make a pilgrimage to the Kaaba and wanted to return home after completing his pilgrimage. The Quraysh disagreed. The Muslims demanded to be allowed to enter Mecca by force, but he refused so as not to disrespect the Kaaba. The Quraysh and Muslims eventually agreed to sign a peace treaty. The Prophet (AS) dictated the peace treaty to ali (AS), who wrote it. The Prophet (AS) commanded him to write: “In the name of Allah, the benefactor, the merciful.” Suhayl ibn `Amr, who represented the Quraysh, protested and said, “This is your slogan that we do not know. Write, “In your name, O Allah!” “I met the Prophet with a group of people from Thaqif and accepted Islam. We asked him to sign an agreement with us and accept our terms. The Prophet commanded us to write down whatever we wanted, and then bring it to him for him to see.
We asked for permission to practice usury and adultery. As we could not put it in writing, we visited `Ali ibn Abi Talib for this purpose. When we saw that we had such terms, Ali refused to write. We made the request to Khalid ibn Said ibn Al-`As. In this statement, Muslim writes, on the one hand, “The Prophet asked for Ali`s help in erasing the words,” and, on the other hand, he writes, “The Prophet erased the words and wrote.” .